1 2

Collector Station

1960 Topps - Bart Starr #51

1960 Topps - Bart Starr #51

$20.00 USD
$20.00 USD
Sale Sold out
Shipping calculated at checkout.

Low stock: 1 left

This is Bart Starr's 1960 Topps #51 — a genuine piece of NFL royalty from the season that started it all. By 1960, Starr had just led Green Bay to the Western Division championship, the opening act of the most dominant run in NFL history: five championships and back-to-back Super Bowl titles, with Starr named MVP of both Super Bowl I and Super Bowl II. The man on this cardboard is the architect of Titletown.

The 1960 Topps football set is one of the most visually striking issues of the era. Its "pure card" design puts the player photo front and center, with nothing but the player's name, team, and position tucked into a football-shaped icon at the bottom — clean, timeless, and instantly recognizable. The 132-card set is anchored by just a handful of true stars, and Starr at #51 is one of its premier names alongside Jim Brown and Johnny Unitas. PSA has logged over 330 sales on this card, confirming steady, sustained collector demand across all grade tiers.

  • Player: Bart Starr — two-time Super Bowl MVP, five NFL championships, Pro Football Hall of Fame inductee (1977), Green Bay Packers #15 retired
  • Set: 1960 Topps Football, #51 — 132-card single-series NFL set with uniform print run (no short prints)
  • Design: Player-photo-dominant front; green-on-white card back with career stats and a Football Funnies scratch-off quiz
  • Market comps: PSA 4 copies trading in the $88–$109 range; PSA 5 around $87–$190; PSA 6 graded copies reaching $191+; a PSA 7 raw beauty listed at $225. Total PSA auction value tracked at over $61,000 in all-time sales

Vintage Starr cardboard rarely sits long. This is a 65-year-old card of the quarterback who won the Ice Bowl, commanded the greatest dynasty the NFL has ever seen, and remains one of the most beloved figures in football history. Whether you're a Green Bay Packers collector, a vintage Topps football hunter, or building a Hall of Fame quarterback PC, the 1960 Topps Bart Starr #51 belongs in the stack.

Available at Collector Station, Easley, SC. Local pickup available. All sales final. Shipping damage must be reported within 48 hours of delivery with photos.

Accuracy Guarantee: Card prices move fast, so every order is verified for pricing, condition, variant, and inventory accuracy before it ships. In the rare case of a material listing error we’ll contact you and make it right before fulfillment — never for ordinary market movement. See our FAQ.
View full details

Shipping & pickup

  • Standard shipping — $5.99 USPS Ground Advantage / First-Class. Typically 2–5 business days from Easley, SC. Tracked.
  • Express (Priority Mail) — $12.99 USPS Priority Mail. Typically 1–3 business days. Tracked.
  • FREE standard shipping on orders $75+ Automatically applied at checkout. Same delivery window as Standard.
  • Free Express Lane pickup at the store Order online, choose Express Lane Pickup at checkout, pull up to the drive-through window at 210 E Main St, Easley, SC. Same-day staging during open hours.
  • Authenticity Guaranteed — exactly what you paid for Every order is guaranteed authentic, the exact item pictured, and pro-packed to arrive safe. Not right? Notify us within 5 business days of delivery for a refund. All other sales final — no change-of-mind returns. The Guarantee.

Ships from Collector Station, 210 E Main St, Easley, SC 29640. Most orders ship within 1 business day.

  • Ships from Easley, SC Most orders ship within 1 business day. Tracked.
  • Express Lane pickup Drive-through window. Same-day staging during open hours.
  • Authenticity Guaranteed Authentic, the exact item pictured, pro-packed — or your money back. The Guarantee.
  • Trade or sell us this Text (864) 523-7071 for an offer.
25 Years in the hobby
1,126 Ratings · 99.3% positive on eBay
4.7★ from 39 Google Reviews

Product FAQ

About This Product

How fast does this ship?

Most orders ship from Easley, SC within 1 business day. Tracked. Express Lane drive-through pickup available same-day during store hours.

Is this product authentic and from authorized sources?

Yes — sealed wax is sourced from authorized distributors. Slabs are direct from the grading company. Raw singles are pulled from sealed product or vetted submissions.

Can I trade or sell something similar to you?

Yes — text +1-864-523-7071 with details and we will get back with a buy or trade offer.

What is your return policy?

Every order is covered by our Authenticity Guarantee: authentic, the exact item pictured, and shipped safe with pro packing — or we refund it, with notification within 5 business days of delivery. Outside the Guarantee, all sales are final: no returns for change of mind or anything unrelated to authenticity or a true misrepresentation. Full pledge at /policies/refund-policy.