• 1968 Topps Baseball Superstars Killebrew Mays Mantle PSA 5 EX Card #490
1 1

Topps

1968 Topps Baseball Superstars Killebrew Mays Mantle PSA 5 EX Card #490

1968 Topps Baseball Superstars Killebrew Mays Mantle PSA 5 EX Card #490

$325.00 USD
$325.00 USD
Sale Sold out
Shipping calculated at checkout.

Out of stock

Want to know when this is back?

1968 Topps #490 "Super Stars" — Mickey Mantle / Willie Mays / Harmon Killebrew — PSA 5 EX

Three of the era's most dominant sluggers share a single card in Topps' 1968 baseball issue — and all three are Hall of Famers, making this one of the most highly sought-after combo cards Topps ever produced. Collectively, these three athletes belted over 1,750 home runs and amassed over 7,750 hits — representing the Yankees, Giants, and Twins all on one piece of cardboard.

Card #490 falls in the high-number series (cards 458–598), which are slightly more difficult to obtain than earlier issues in the set. Cards in this 598-card set measure the standard 2½" by 3½" , and the key Rookie Cards in the set are Johnny Bench and Nolan Ryan — giving the set serious blue-chip company for the #490 to compete with on any want list.

  • Mickey Mantle — New York Yankees — one of the most iconic names in the hobby
  • Willie Mays — San Francisco Giants — a 24-time All-Star, 12-time Gold Glove winner, and two-time NL MVP
  • Harmon Killebrew — Minnesota Twins — retired with 573 home runs and 1,584 RBI; elected to the Hall of Fame in 1984

PSA auction records show over 1,040 total auction sales for this card with a cumulative value exceeding $481,000 , underscoring the depth of collector demand across all grades. A PSA Gem Mint 10 example sold for $7,713 — and the PSA 5 EX grade represents a sharply collected, authenticated slab that puts this three-HOFer centerpiece squarely within reach. Active eBay comps for graded examples of this card show a consistent market in the $100–$165 range for mid-grade PSA slabs, with strong liquidity at every level.

This is vintage Topps at its most powerful: three immortals, one card, one slab. Whether you're building a 1968 Topps set, a Mickey Mantle PC, a Willie Mays collection, or a Harmon Killebrew player collection, this PSA 5 delivers authenticated, displayable history from the Golden Age of baseball.

Available at Collector Station, Easley, SC. Local pickup available. All sales final. Shipping damage must be reported within 48 hours of delivery with photos.

Accuracy Guarantee: Card prices move fast, so every order is verified for pricing, condition, variant, and inventory accuracy before it ships. In the rare case of a material listing error we’ll contact you and make it right before fulfillment — never for ordinary market movement. See our FAQ.
View full details

Shipping & pickup

  • Standard shipping — $5.99 USPS Ground Advantage / First-Class. Typically 2–5 business days from Easley, SC. Tracked.
  • Express (Priority Mail) — $12.99 USPS Priority Mail. Typically 1–3 business days. Tracked.
  • FREE standard shipping on orders $75+ Automatically applied at checkout. Same delivery window as Standard.
  • Free Express Lane pickup at the store Order online, choose Express Lane Pickup at checkout, pull up to the drive-through window at 210 E Main St, Easley, SC. Same-day staging during open hours.
  • Authenticity Guaranteed — exactly what you paid for Every order is guaranteed authentic, the exact item pictured, and pro-packed to arrive safe. Not right? Notify us within 5 business days of delivery for a refund. All other sales final — no change-of-mind returns. The Guarantee.

Ships from Collector Station, 210 E Main St, Easley, SC 29640. Most orders ship within 1 business day.

  • Ships from Easley, SC Most orders ship within 1 business day. Tracked.
  • Express Lane pickup Drive-through window. Same-day staging during open hours.
  • Authenticity Guaranteed Authentic, the exact item pictured, pro-packed — or your money back. The Guarantee.
  • Trade or sell us this Text (864) 523-7071 for an offer.
25 Years in the hobby
1,126 Ratings · 99.3% positive on eBay
4.7★ from 39 Google Reviews

Product FAQ

About This Product

How fast does this ship?

Most orders ship from Easley, SC within 1 business day. Tracked. Express Lane drive-through pickup available same-day during store hours.

Is this product authentic and from authorized sources?

Yes — sealed wax is sourced from authorized distributors. Slabs are direct from the grading company. Raw singles are pulled from sealed product or vetted submissions.

Can I trade or sell something similar to you?

Yes — text +1-864-523-7071 with details and we will get back with a buy or trade offer.

What is your return policy?

Every order is covered by our Authenticity Guarantee: authentic, the exact item pictured, and shipped safe with pro packing — or we refund it, with notification within 5 business days of delivery. Outside the Guarantee, all sales are final: no returns for change of mind or anything unrelated to authenticity or a true misrepresentation. Full pledge at /policies/refund-policy.